Filing the claim is not the end of the story. Every claim is reviewed by the insolvency administrator, and its validity, amount and ranking can be disputed by the administrator, the debtor and other creditors who have filed claims (Section 192 of the Insolvency Act). A dispute has serious consequences – and the time to defend yourself is very short.
When the administrator disputes your claim
For a non-enforceable claim (typically unpaid invoices without a judgment), you must bring an action before the insolvency court within 30 days of the review hearing to determine the validity, amount or ranking of the claim. The period does not end earlier than 15 days after you receive notice of the dispute. If you miss it, a claim disputed as to validity is disregarded, and a claim disputed as to amount or ranking is established only to the extent it was not disputed (Section 198 of the Insolvency Act).
For an enforceable claim (for example one awarded by a judgment), it is the other way round – the administrator who disputed it must bring the action. Even then, your interests need to be actively defended in the ancillary dispute.
When you want to dispute another creditor’s claim
Every inflated or fictitious claim reduces the share you will receive. A creditor who has filed a claim may dispute another creditor’s claim on the prescribed form no later than three working days before the review hearing (Section 200 of the Insolvency Act). The objection must be properly reasoned and supported.
What we will do for you
- assess the grounds for the dispute and your chances of success,
- prepare and file the action to determine the claim (an ancillary dispute) in time,
- prepare an objection to another creditor’s claim where appropriate,
- represent you in the ancillary dispute and in dealings with the insolvency administrator.
